Read what some of our satisfied insurance customers have to say! If you’d like to provide your feedback, please submit your online review.
Fred R., Olean, New York“We love doing business with local people that you run into at the grocery store. The combination of Erie Insurance and the Bantleman Agency is like the perfect match. We recently had an accident and the service we received from both our Agent, Maryann Zitnik, and the claims agent from Erie Insurance was absolutely flawless. I appreciated the quick reaction from the agency and the genuine care they had for the well-being of my wife and children. These people are surely some of the best the Olean area has to offer!”
- Jim B., Olean, New York
“Been my insurance carrier for years. Great value insurance with expert advice. đź‘Ź”
- Jennifer F., Olean, New York
“Joe is great to work with for all our insurance. They are extremely professional and available to answer any questions when needed. Great having someone local to deal with.”
- SFSteve F., Olean, New York
“Great cust service! Affordable insurance,
Cust for life!!” - MSMike S., Olean, New York
“Nice employees”
- NWNancy W., Olean, New York
“Shannon is excellent to work with.”
- KBkyle b., Olean, New York
“I have recently switched to Bantelman Agency from one of the larger insurance companies. They have been the insurance provider for Olean Union Sales for years and have done a great job, and make things easy. I decided to make the switch and couldn’t be happier. Maryanne is wonderful to deal with and is always willing to go above and beyond. I am happy to support another local business and will continue to do so. Oh and did I add that they saved me a good amount of money. I would highly reccomend you give this local business a try.”
- Rob A., Olean, New York
“Jenn was amazing. She quoted me for my home, motorcycle and 2 vehicles and saved me over 1400 dollars a year! Never thought anyone could beat USAA but they did, and by a ton. Thank you for helping!”
- RBRachel B., Olean, New York
“They’re the best! I have used the Bantelman Agency since I started driving for car insurance, I now use them for homeowners and business insurance. Their rates are always the most affordable (for auto, home and business) and their service is unmatched. I am always able to get ahold of the principle agents when I have issues/needs and as a small business owner, it’s really helpful to be able to have my questions answered so quickly by Mary Anne and/or Joe.”
- David B., Olean, New York
“Awesome service, found me the best possible alternative to go with my auto and homeowners, saving me thousands (really, over $2000). The girls in the office are second to none when it comes to work ethic, I cannot say enough. Thank you for being in my corner!!!!”
- Allen S., Olean, New York
“Bantelman is a blessing! Easy to work with, and willing to go above and beyond for their customers!”
- BBBrentt B., Olean, New York
“Saved me 5,268 dollars annually.”
- AMAngie M., Olean, New York
“Jillana was extremely helpful and made the transition so easy. She saved me over $500.00 a year. Thank you Jillana.
” - EBErik B., Olean, NY
“I had a great experience with Jillana and they also had the best price I could find.
” - TBTaylor B., Olean, NY
“Jillana Corbett was able to save me $792.00 a year while also giving me better coverage on my car insurance. Thank you!
”
